Getting ready
Design completion, programming, tooling and dies, workholding and fixtures, test development, first-article inspection.
Economics
Much of the cost of a small run can be decided before the first good part: design and proof work, tooling, fixtures, programming and setup. Other costs scale with every unit made. Knowing which is which tells you when a route starts to make sense, and what a quote will hinge on.
A simple model gets you a long way: total cost equals the one-time cost of getting ready, plus a per-unit cost times the number of units. A route with expensive tooling and cheap units wins at volume; a flexible route with no tooling and dearer units wins at low volume. Somewhere between them is a crossover, and finding it is most of the job.
Design completion, programming, tooling and dies, workholding and fixtures, test development, first-article inspection.
Material and the share of it that becomes scrap, machine and labor time, inspection, rework.
Packaging, freight, lead time and any inventory someone has to hold.
Every money, time and output figure in this model is an illustrative teaching assumption in USD. None is a quote from a manufacturer or an equipment supplier. Quantity means acceptable empty packages delivered at the same agreed function, print target and finished quality.
A campaign needs 2,400 empty corrugated mailers: one shared structure, eight different printed designs, 300 of each. Three routes are compared, all assumed to deliver the same box at the same quality. Digital printing changes the image straight from a file; flexographic printing transfers it from a plate made for each design. A CAD cutting table follows a programmed path across every sheet; a cutting die carries the pattern and stamps it.
The fixed inputs are $900 for common structural design and proof work and $50 of artwork preparation per version. Digital print setup is pooled at $250 and cutting setup at $200. Routes B and C use one $1,500 structural die. Route C adds a $600 plate set and $200 of print setup for each artwork version. With eight versions, these inputs produce fixed costs of $1,750, $3,250 and $9,400.
The assumed variable rates include board, ink, direct conversion, ordinary finishing and routine production waste per accepted package. Setup includes make-ready work and associated waste. Freight, taxes, sales margin, capital recovery, general overhead, exceptional rework and custom product inserts are excluded. This compares route costs; it is not an all-in commercial quote.
The shared-die and pooled-setup assumptions require the same compatible substrate and structure. Different structures, board thickness, coatings, die, glue pattern or pack-out can break that pooling. Shared plate layouts or partial plate changes would also need a different model.
No plates and no die. One-time costs $1,750; $3.40 a box. Total for 2,400 boxes: $9,910.
The die costs $1,500 but serves all eight designs. One-time costs $3,250; $2.00 a box. Total: $8,050.
Cheapest per box, but each design needs its own plate set and press setup. One-time costs $9,400; $1.35 a box. Total: $12,640.
The shared die pays for itself early. It costs $1,500 and saves $1.40 a box against the CAD table, so it breaks even at about 1,071 boxes. The common structure is doing the work: each design is only 300 boxes, but the die sees all 2,400.
For B versus C, let k be the number of artwork versions. The extra fixed cost is $800k minus $250: $600 of plates plus $200 of flexo print setup per artwork, less B’s pooled digital print setup. The shared design, artwork preparation, die and cutting setup cancel. Divide by C’s $0.65 per-package saving: crossover = ($800k − $250) ÷ $0.65. At eight versions that is $6,150 ÷ $0.65, about 9,462 acceptable packages; at one version it is $550 ÷ $0.65, about 846. The number of versions moves the answer as much as the total volume does.
Suppose the same design, artwork, die and plate sets are already usable and paid for, and the reorder needs no new proof work. A and B each incur $450 in print and cutting setups; C incurs $1,800. Under the same assumptions, B costs $450 plus $2.00 a package and C costs $1,800 plus $1.35. Their incremental crossover is ($1,800 − $450) ÷ $0.65, about 2,077 acceptable packages. At 2,400, C costs $5,040 against B’s $5,250.
The first tools still belong in the program’s lifetime economics; they are sunk only for this repeat-order choice. Reuse requires the same usable revisions and a real right to access the tooling. Storage, maintenance and replacement costs must be added where they differ. A launch and a stable replenishment order can favor different routes.
Assume each of the eight artworks has a 30% chance of one revision after plates are made but before printing. A revision needs $60 of file and proof work on either route; C additionally replaces a modeled $600 plate set. Expected extra plate cost is 8 × 0.30 × $600 = $1,440. Under these assumptions the B-to-C first-campaign crossover rises to ($6,150 + $1,440) ÷ $0.65, about 11,677 packages.
Changes after printing can obsolete output on either route. Flexible prepress keeps the artwork choice open before the sheet is printed; it does not preserve that option after printing. This is a specific learning period, not a measured result.
Common unprinted board can potentially serve whichever compatible artwork version is needed before printing commits it. The intermediate must remain usable by the variants, and final customization must fit inside the remaining lead time. Sharing material and setup does not by itself prove an inventory saving: correlated demand, substitution limits and the real demand distribution change the result.
Cost is not delivery. Suppose folding, gluing and bundling run at 300 boxes an hour after a one-hour setup, and the finishing area has 12 workable hours before the ship date, 4 of them already promised to other work. Seven productive hours make 2,100 boxes, 300 short of the order. Switching print routes doesn’t help, because printing was never the constraint. The fixes are about finishing: another hour, a simpler closure, a second qualified finishing route, or a later promise.
No prices, margins or investment returns for any real company or request appear on this site. Where numbers appear, they are labeled assumptions, and the arithmetic is shown so you can replace them with your own.